Poland
Poland exhibits mid-range performance across all four categories of the Global State of Democracy (GSoD) framework, and performs in the top 25 per cent globally in several factors. Between 2018 and 2023, Poland experienced significant declines in Representation, Credible Elections, Elected Government and Freedom of Expression. There have been no significant advances in Poland over this period. However, there have been recent steps towards democratic reform, including measures to safeguard the independence of judges and prosecutors, as well as the state media. Poland boasts a high-income economy that features dynamic automotive and aerospace, information technology, pharmaceutical and financial services sectors. Levels of income inequality in Poland are among the highest in Europe, with pronounced regional disparities. After a protracted brain drain, there are signs that recent economic growth, and particularly a vibrant information technology sector, is attracting members of the Polish diaspora to return.
Under the rule of Mieszko I in the 10th century, Polish tribes were united in a centralized state, yet Poland’s borders continued to evolve over the years. The state was partitioned by Russia, Prussia and Austria at the end of the 18th century, before Poland regained independence at the end of World War I. Historical memory, rooted in the experiences of World War II and decades as a satellite state of the Soviet Union, has left a traumatic legacy. This has often been weaponized by politicians, who use these memories to stir up nationalist sentiments. Following the peaceful fall of communist party rule, Poland transitioned to democracy in 1989. In more recent history, accession to the European Union (EU) in 2004 has sparked ongoing debates around national versus European identity, as well as the relationship between EU membership and national sovereignty. In 2024, the European Commission announced the end of a protracted dispute over the rule of law, during which the EU suspended funding to Poland citing breaches of EU rule of law principles and weak judicial independence, after the Polish government outlined plans for a sweeping judicial overhaul.
Poland has a fairly homogenous population, and features sizeable Silesian, Belarusian and German communities among its national-ethnic minorities, and a growing population of Ukrainian refugees. As immigration has risen over the past decade, authorities have been criticized by human rights organizations for overcrowding and poor conditions in migrant detention centres, as well as for committing violent “pushbacks.” The debate over secularity forms an important cleavage in Polish society, and right-wing parties tend to align themselves with the Catholic Church, using religion to promote “family values” at the expense of the rights of LGBTQIA+ communities as well as reproductive rights.
Poland performs in the mid-range in Gender Equality, shifting from high-range in 2021 in view of 2020 restrictions allowing abortion only under specific circumstances - such as when the mother’s life is at risk or if there are severe fetal defects - and subsequent crackdowns on abortion rights activists. However, recent positive developments impacting Gender Equality include the amendment of a law on domestic violence, including measures to improve protections for victims.
Looking ahead, it will be important to watch Rule of Law, including an ongoing investigation into misuse of the Justice Ministry’s resources intended for crime prevention. Recent legislative proposals to liberalize Poland’s strict abortion laws would improve access to healthcare for pregnant women and women’s reproductive rights more broadly, with impacts on Basic Welfare and Gender Equality. Finally, it will be important to watch recent legislation decriminalizing the use of weapons in border management for impacts on Social Group Equality and the Personal Integrity and Security of migrants. Impacts on Freedom of the Press can also be expected following the recent re-introduction of a border "exclusion zone" affecting the access of journalists and humanitarian workers to border areas.
Last updated: September 2024
https://www.idea.int/democracytracker/
October 2024
Government tables same-sex partnerships bill
On 19 October, the government introduced a bill that would provide for the legal recognition of same-sex partnerships. The legislation would allow unmarried adults to register a partnership with the registry office, providing greater legal protections for healthcare and inheritance, among other rights. The bill is an important step in view of the restrictions the LGBTQIA+ community suffered in Poland under the previous government, and represents a significant step in the government’s commitment to improving the rights of Poland’s LGBTQIA+ citizens. The bill is currently open to public consultation and will undergo ministerial review as a next step, after which the bill needs to be approved by Parliament and signed into law by the President. In December 2023, a European Court of Human Rights ruling found that Poland’s failure to recognize same-sex partnerships violates human rights and required the government to provide adequate recognition of same-sex relationships.
Sources: International IDEA, Notes from Poland, Legislacja, Reuters
New migration strategy includes suspension of asylum rights
On 15 October, the government adopted a migration strategy for 2025-2030 that makes it possible to temporarily suspend the right to seek asylum in the event of a national security threat. The strategy cites “organised and controlled” migration from Belarus and Russia to justify the measure. The decision was opposed by local and international NGOs, who argued that it contravenes EU law and Poland’s obligations under the 1951 Refugee Convention to uphold the fundamental right to seek asylum. The strategy also outlines reforms designed to strengthen the impartiality of consular officers issuing visas, addressing irregularities in the visa system that occurred under the previous government. Additionally, the strategy proposes new requirements for accessing the labour market, including making work permits contingent on an employment contract and increasing penalties for the illegal employment of foreign nationals.
Sources: European Council on Refugees and Exiles, Government of Poland, International IDEA, Amnesty International, Notes from Poland, Onet, Euronews
August 2024
Government eases abortion procedures
On 30 August, the government published new guidelines for hospitals and prosecutors, aiming to ease abortion access. The guidelines state that one doctor’s opinion confirming that the health of the mother is endangered is sufficient to terminate a pregnancy. Previously, healthcare providers often required opinions from several doctors or the convening of a medical board before offering access to a lawful abortion. Under the current law, abortion is legal only in cases where the mother’s health or life is at risk or if the pregnancy is the result of a crime. The guidelines also ensure access to an abortion on the grounds of protection of the mother’s mental health. A recent report from UN experts noted excessive requirements by certain hospitals, such as a certificate by a Catholic psychologist. This comes after an earlier development in June, when the government lifted the “conscience clause” that allows doctors to refuse to perform an abortion if it contradicts their beliefs.
Sources: International IDEA (1), International IDEA (2), Notes from Poland (1), Notes from Poland (2), UN News, Chancellery of the Prime Minister, Center for Reproductive Rights
Electoral Commission finds violation of campaign financing regulations
On 29 August, the National Electoral Commission (PKW) issued a fine to the former governing party, Law and Justice (PiS), for violating campaign financing regulations during the 2023 parliamentary elections. The Commission determined that PiS had illegally spent USD 930,738 (over PLN 3 million) of public funds for its campaign. The Commission stated that PiS took advantage of public military events as an opportunity for campaigning and stated that the party paid employees of government agencies to campaign on the party’s behalf. Owing to the violations of campaign funding, PiS will have its publicly-funded campaign allowance reduced by USD 2.59 million (nearly three times the total irregular spending identified in 2023), and receive cuts to its annual state funding, lasting until the 2027 parliamentary elections. PiS has the opportunity to appeal to the Supreme Court, and has claimed the decision aims to undermine the party’s chances in the 2025 presidential elections.
Sources: Reuters, Politico, Bloomberg, 300 Polityka, Notes from Poland, PKW, OSCE
July 2024
Sejm approves legislation decriminalizing use of weapons in border management
On 12 July, the Sejm, Poland’s lower parliamentary house, approved amendments to the Homeland Defence Act and the Criminal Code, which exempts soldiers, border guards and police officers from criminal liability for the use of weapons against migrants attempting to cross into Poland under certain conditions. These circumstances include cases of self-defence or failure to comply with a request to surrender a weapon, explosive or “other dangerous item.” Legal experts point to the risk of the broad interpretation of a “dangerous item.” The amendments also provide officers accused of improper use of weapons with financial support to obtain legal assistance. The amendments were approved with overwhelming support (401 votes in favour and 17 against). The Defense Ministry introduced the legislation on 21 June after two soldiers were suspended from duty and charged with exceeding their powers after firing warning shots towards a group of migrants at the border with Belarus, sparking fierce political debate.
Sources: Notes from Poland (1), Notes from Poland (2), Rzeczpospolita, Sejm (1), Sejm (2), International IDEA
June 2024
Government re-introduces controversial border ‘exclusion zone’
Following the death of a Polish soldier who was stabbed by a migrant attempting to cross the border on 29 May, the government re-introduced a controversial ‘exclusion zone’, in force as of 13 June for 90 days. The decision creates a restricted area on the Polish side of the border, where only local residents and authorised uniformed officers may enter. Any other individuals, including journalists, must apply to a border guard for a pass to enter. The zone was introduced by the previous government in 2021 and has been heavily criticised by NGOs for impacts on press freedom and the provision of humanitarian aid. The government has stated that the buffer zone aims to hamper the operations of smuggling groups and has accused Belarusian authorities of orchestrating migration to put pressure on Poland.
Sources: Notes from Poland, DW, European Council on Refugees and Exiles, Fundacja Ocalenie
See all event reports for this country
Global ranking per category of democratic performance in 2023
Basic Information
Human Rights Treaties
Performance by category over the last 6 months
Blogs
Global State of Democracy Indices
Hover over the trend lines to see the exact data points across the years
Factors of Democratic Performance Over Time
Use the slider below to see how democratic performance has changed over time