Kyrgyzstan
Kyrgyzstan is a low-performing country in every core measure of the Global State of Democracy framework: Participation, Representation, Rights and Rule of Law. Over the last five years, it has experienced significant declines in Rule of Law, Civil Liberties, Effective Parliament and Judicial Independence as President Sadyr Japarov centralized political power and undermined checks and balances. Kyrgyzstan is a lower middle-income country with a domestic economy based on agriculture and gold mining, and a quarter of the population lives under the national poverty line. Kyrgyzstan is one of the most remittance-dependent countries in the world, with money sent home – mostly from Russia – accounts for 30 per cent of GDP.
Kyrgyzstan is a multiethnic country (77 per cent Kyrgyz, 14 per cent Uzbek, and with small Dungan, Uyghur, and Russian minorities) with a young population, whose politics have historically been driven by regionally-based patronage and organized criminal groups. Since gaining independence from the Soviet Union in 1991, it has seen six constitutional amendment processes that repeatedly renegotiated electoral, political, and power-sharing systems. In 2005, the Tulip Revolution, triggered by dissatisfaction with authoritarianism and corruption resulted in the resignation of the country’s president since independence, and in 2010 a revolution that grew out of clashes between minority Uzbek and majority Kyrgyz communities in the south resulted in a shift from a presidential to a parliamentary system.
Recently, economic interests have taken political precedence over regional identity, as was visible in the 2015 elections and violent governmental turnover in 2020. The nationalist-populist Japarov rose to power in late 2020 following widely-criticized elections. Japarov’s rise was fueled in part by dissatisfaction with the government’s COVID-19 response and subsequent economic crisis, general negative public attitudes towards the government, and anti-establishment sentiment among oligarchs. The new administration oversaw a 2021 referendum that transitioned Kyrgyzstan from a parliamentary to a fully presidential system, vesting more power in the president’s office and raising concerns of entrenching authoritarianism.
Kyrgyzstan has long been caught between the geopolitical interests of Russia (which has several military bases and is the major migrant destination country) and China (which is the main investor and creditor). Poor border demarcation, which complicates pressing regional questions of access to water and enclaves, is a persistent issue with neighboring Uzbekistan, and a disputed border with Tajikistan was the background for 2022 Kyrgyz-Tajik clashes that resulted in dozens of deaths and tens of thousands of internally displaced people.
Recent years have seen further worrying signs for Kyrgyzstan’s democratic trajectory, including arrests of civil activists, journalists, and politicians, and growing pressure on independent media. Gender-based violence has long been a systemic issue, and reports from human rights activists argue that even assessing its extent is difficult due to underreporting, a lack of support services, and ineffective legal protections. Public charges of corruption against top ministers and the head of the Central Electoral Committee frequently go unpunished, or the accused are let off with a fine. Historically, civil society in Kyrgyzstan has been able to withstand rising autocratization and decelerate democratic decline through active public protest and engagement. However, President Japarov’s weakening of parliament, pressure on courts, and attacks on freedom of expression might impact the Rule of Law, Effective Parliament and Civil Liberties in the years to come.
Last updated: June 2024
https://www.idea.int/democracytracker/
May 2024
Exodus of foreign students after dormitory clash
Hundreds of Pakistani university students fled Kyrgyzstan in May 2024 after a seemingly minor altercation between Pakistani students and Kyrgyz youth at a Bishkek restaurant escalated into the storming of an international student dormitory by 700 Kyrgyz youths. The attacks resulted in 41 hospitalizations and by 20 May, 1,200 Pakistani students at Kyrgyzstan International University had returned home. Observers credited the escalation and violence with growing sentiments – that the government has been unable or unwilling to counteract - that South Asians are replacing Kyrgyz workers in areas where foreign students often take part-time jobs such as taxis, food couriers, and car washes.
Sources: Eurasianet, Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, Havli
April 2024
Japarov signs foreign agents law
President Sadyr Japarov signed into law on 2 April a bill requiring all non-governmental organizations (NGOs) that receive foreign funding to register as ‘“foreign representatives’” and be subjected to reporting and audit requirements. Organizations that do not comply will face strict penalties, and the text defines NGOs broadly enough to include schools, sports clubs, and children’s organizations, but how and where the law will be enforced is unclear. Some NGOs have proactively ceased operations to avoid future fines for noncompliance, and the Open Society Foundations closed its long-running grant-making operation in the country to avoid either it or its grant recipients being targeted by the law. The Kyrgyz state has outsourced much social service provision, including healthcare and education, to foreign-funded NGOs for decades and the impact of the law on socioeconomic conditions is expected to be significant.
Sources: The Diplomat, Eurasianet, Open Society Foundations
TikTok banned to protect children’s health
Kyrgyzstan’s Ministry of Digital Development blocked TikTok in the country on 17 April, following the conclusion of the State Committee for National Security that the app harmed ‘“the health of children [and] their intellectual, mental, spiritual and moral development.’” Reporters without Borders (RSF) criticized the ban for restricting freedom of expression and information. The ban follows a string of arrests and pressure on independent media outlets in the country that long had the most open media environment in the region.
Sources: Eurasianet, Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty
February 2024
‘Foreign representatives’ bill moves forward amid outcry
Kyrgyzstan’s parliament approved the second reading of a much-criticized ‘foreign representatives’ bill on the second reading on 22 February. The draft bill requires NGOs that receive foreign funding to register as “foreign representatives”, submit annual audits, and be subjected to other bureaucratic requirements that critics say will require most to cease operations. The bill has been criticized by domestic civil society, international human rights NGOs, OSCE officials, and the United States government for its negative impact on civil society in the country, who have noted its close relation to Russia’s infamous “foreign agent” legislation. The bill is expected to pass a third reading and be signed into law by President Sadyr Japarov, who has championed the bill and singled out American criticism as hypocritical, citing the dissimilar but similarly named American Foreign Agents Registration Act.
Sources: Eurasianet (1), Eurasianet (2), The Diplomat, Civil Rights Defenders
January 2024
International outcry over media crackdown
International human rights groups called for Kyrgyzstan to drop criminal charges against six independent media organizations on 16 January following police raids on the homes of numerous journalists and newsrooms. The Interior Ministry claims it is investigating “war propaganda” and “calls to mass disorder” in the media outlets’ reporting, under various statutes which carry penalties of up to eight years in prison. It is unclear what reporting the charges relate to, although journalists from the 24.kg news agency’s questioning indicated some are related to their coverage of Russia’s war on Ukraine. The raids come in the wake of legal pressure such as the attempted closures and blocking of websites of other independent and critical media outlets in recent months, and a draft media law that has been criticized by United Nations experts, domestic media, and rights organizations as overly restrictive.
Update: On 10 October 2024, a Bishkek court sentenced two journalists from Temirov Live for organizing “calls for mass unrest” to five and six years in prison. Two more were given three years’ probation. The sentences were condemned by local journalists and international press freedom watchdogs.
Sources: Eurasianet, Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, Radio Azattyk, United Nations, International IDEA, The Diplomat, Committee to Protect Journalists
See all event reports for this country
Global ranking per category of democratic performance in 2023
Basic Information
Human Rights Treaties
Performance by category over the last 6 months
Global State of Democracy Indices
Hover over the trend lines to see the exact data points across the years
Factors of Democratic Performance Over Time
Use the slider below to see how democratic performance has changed over time