Peru
Peru performs in the mid-range across all four categories of democracy. It is among the top 25 per cent of countries globally in several factors of Representation, Rights and Participation. Compared to 2018, Peru has experienced significant declines in Free Political Parties, Elected Government, Effective Parliament, Civil Liberties, Freedom of the Press, Freedom of Association and Assembly, Economic Equality and Absence of Corruption. In recent years, instability has been notable, exemplified by the fact that in the last ten years Peru has had seven presidents. Peru is an upper-middle income country that is heavily reliant on commodity exports such as copper, gold and animal products.
Peru gained independence from Spain in the early nineteenth century. Its early political landscape was characterized by instability and a succession of governments of both conservative and liberal leanings, but also military rule. From 1968 to 1980, a military junta that emphasized labor and agrarian reform ruled the country. However, poverty rates and inequality in land ownership prevailed. In response to the rise of the Maoist group Sendero Luminoso – which demanded radical land redistribution – the 1990s were marked by the brutal “People’s War” between the Sendero Luminoso and the government. The war resulted in an estimated 70,000 deaths. A truth commission that investigated the widespread human rights violations that were committed during the conflict eventually tried and convicted then-president Alberto Fujimori for some of these violations (though controversially pardoned in 2023 on ‘humanitarian grounds’). The country returned to democracy in 2001, but the legacy of the armed conflict continues to shape politics. This is partly due to continued socioeconomic and racial inequality, the urban-rural divide, and opposition to and support for Fujimorismo, which belie political polarization.
A fragmented political party system and the repeated use of impeachment, moral incapacity claims and dissolution of Congress have contributed to persistent conflict between the executive and the opposition-led legislature. This, in turn, has hindered government functionality. In December 2022, this situation reached a boiling point, and former President Pedro Castillo was impeached and arrested after attempting to dissolve Congress. Since then, the country has been engulfed in a string of protests and calls for early elections, some of which have been violent. Additional contentious issues include allegations of corruption and calls by several groups and parties for a new constitution, which have not materialized yet, to address democratic discontent. Amendments to the constitution that reinstated bicameralism and re-election of lawmakers, and concerns over an imbalance between branches of government, are further salient issues.
Indigenous Peoples comprise 45 per cent of the country’s population, but despite constitutional and legal protections they face political disempowerment, exclusion from social services, land encroachment and disproportionate levels of poverty due to lack of enforcement and racial bias. Relatedly, environmental activists and Indigenous leaders are frequently subject to intimidation, harassment, and stigmatization. Other minorities (Afro-Peruvians), and LGBTQIA+ people and women face pervasive discrimination and violence. After a 2020 law requiring equal representation, the country has made strides toward greater gender parity in politics, and currently 38.5 per cent of congressmembers are women. However, widespread gender-based violence remains a serious problem and Peruvian women and girls, especially from Indigenous communities, are vulnerable to sex trafficking.
Looking ahead, Absence of Corruption and Representation-related factors will continue to be key for government functionality and the continuity of policies. It will also be important to follow measures to contain declines in Civil Liberties and Economic Equality, including possible constitutional reforms, particularly in the context of discontent with social and racial inequality and political instability.
Last Updated: June 2024
https://www.idea.int/democracytracker/
September 2024
Retired member of the military convicted of historic crimes
A chamber of the National Specialized Criminal Court convicted Alberto Rivero Valdeavellano, who in 1984 acted as chief of military command in Huanta, of crimes tantamount to crimes against humanity, committed in the context of Peru’s internal armed conflict (1980-2000). The chamber determined his responsibility as direct perpetrator of the enforced disappearance of journalist Jaime Ayala and 45 other people, including peasants from the Culluchaca community. He was also found responsible as indirect perpetrator of the murder of 17 people. Rivero was sentenced to 18 years imprisonment. The resolution regarding Augusto Gabilondo García del Barco, another former official charged in the same case is pending, as he is a fugitive. In an exercise of constitutional control, in García del Barco’s case, the chamber disapplied recently enacted legislation that introduced a statute of limitations on crimes against humanity, considering it is contrary to the constitution and Peru’s international obligations, upholding the charges against him. The judgment has been appealed.
Sources: Estado Peruano, La República , APRODEH, Infobae, LatAm Journalism Review, El País, International IDEA
July 2024
Congress passes statute of limitations on crimes against humanity
Congress has passed a bill, through which a statute of limitations will be set to crimes against humanity and war crimes committed before 1 July 2002 (date in which the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court entered into force). Lawmakers pushed the piece of legislation through despite provisional measures by the Inter-American Court of Human Rights ordering the Peruvian state to halt it. A group of UN Special Rapporteurs and the Committee on Enforced Disappearances had also cautioned that establishing a statute of limitations to such atrocity crimes constitutes a transgression to a peremptory norm of international law. Human rights experts have further highlighted that the bill severely undermines access to justice efforts for victims of the internal armed conflict that took place in the country between 1980 and 2000.
Sources: Radio Nacional Peru, Centro para la Justicia y el Derecho Internacional, BBC, El País (1), El País (2), OHCHR
May 2024
Government classifies trans identity as a mental health disorder
The Health Ministry published a decree in which it introduced changes to policy on health insurance coverage. The decree classifies transgender identity and other expressions of gender and sexual diversity as ‘mental health problems’ that are to be covered by private and public insurance. Protests and widespread criticism of the classification led to the Ministry issuing a statement that the decree’s classification was necessary to ensure access to mental health services for members of the LGBTQIA+ community, especially for those with private health insurance. Officials have contended that this modification will facilitate billing services to private insurers. Activists and other experts criticize the classification for relying on World Health Organization terminology that is no longer in use. They further argue it could potentially enable harmful practices such as conversion therapy, on account of its stigmatizing and discriminatory terms and given the national context where many rights are not recognized, and violence against LGBTQIA+ people is common.
Update: Through a subsequent regulation, the Ministry of Health added new codes in June and removed the classification of these expressions of gender identity as mental health problems.
Sources: Infobae, CNN, El Pais, Diario Oficial El Peruano, New York Times, MINSA
March 2024
National Board of Justice members are suspended, later reinstated
Congress suspended two members (Ines Tello and Aldo Vasquez) of the National Board of Justice (Junta Nacional de Justicia, JNJ), in a process criticized by experts and human rights organizations as undermining judicial independence. Some analysts also consider this an attempt by Congress to influence the appointment of judges and heads of electoral authorities, given the JNJ’s authority on the subject. Tello and Vasquez were also determined to be ineligible to hold public office, after being accused of contravening a constitutional provision on the age limit of the Board’s members. The decision to remove the two members was approved by the minimum required votes. At least one lawmaker voted in contravention of rules that prevent members of the Permanent Commission from taking part in the decision, sparking further criticism. Days later, Lima’s Supreme Constitutional Chamber reinstated the JNJ members pending the appeal process. Congress rejected the Chamber’s decision and has announced new accusations against the JNJ.
Sources: La Republica (1), Human Rights Watch, La Republica (2), Deutsche Welle, El Pais, International IDEA
Constitutional reform reinstates bicameralism
A constitutional reform amendment, that transforms the legislature into a bicameral body, starting in 2026, was promulgated on 20 March after being passed by Congress. Once the next Congress is elected, a Senate comprised of 60 elected representatives (serving five-year terms) will be reinstated. In 1993, Congress became a one chamber legislature during Fujimorismo. The reform also includes provisions that will reinstate the ability of legislators to run for re-election. Critics argue that the measure directly contravenes the results of a 2018 referendum, in which both bicameralism and reelection of legislators was rejected by a wide margin. However, proponents of the amendment have highlighted that the 2018 referendum considered a different form of bicameralism that would have undermined the balance of powers. Those who support the reform argue that the Senate will contribute to a better functioning of Congress by overseeing inquiries initiated by the Chamber of Deputies and ensure a speedier and more efficient lawmaking process. Supporters of reelection say it enables the professionalization of politics.
Sources: Congress of Peru, Infobae, France 24
See all event reports for this country
Global ranking per category of democratic performance in 2023
Basic Information
Human Rights Treaties
Performance by category over the last 6 months
Blogs
Global State of Democracy Indices
Hover over the trend lines to see the exact data points across the years
Factors of Democratic Performance Over Time
Use the slider below to see how democratic performance has changed over time